You are viewing usomitai

存在していない世界 (non-existant world) - ccs memorial clamp interview [entries|archive|friends|userinfo]
ベル物 (bell)

[ website | fic index ]
[ userinfo | livejournal userinfo ]
[ archive | journal archive ]

ccs memorial clamp interview [Apr. 22nd, 2005|12:26 am]
ベル物 (bell)
[Tags|, , ]
[Current Mood |wrists ouchie]
[Current Music |tori amos: scarlet's trail album [I can't see New York]]

Japan Times article on being an otayome- wife of an otaku. Amusing read and probably needs to be taken with a grain of salt, but still I shake my head. Did these two KNOW each other before getting married? Surely she should've known that her fiance filled his living room with figurines and talking about 60s anime directors. And what about him, marrying a woman who thinks far too much about tables? Just b/c you have an obsession (be it computers or fashion) doesn't mean you are (or have to be) socially incompetent or marry just anyone b/c you're desperate.

Moving onwards, version 1.15 of the Clamp interview in the CCS Memorial Book. Thanks again to canis_m and iamsocool12345 for their fantastic Japanese knowledge. The usual applies: [] indicates thoughts, and if you find any mistakes (language/grammar/spelling/whatever) let me know. ^_^

QUESTION: When did you first come up with the idea for Card Captor Sakura?

OHKAWA: We were close to finishing Magic Knight Rayearth, the manga we were serializing in Nakayoshi before CCS, when our head editor Yamonouchi-san (who has been so supportive) asked us to do another series with them. With MKR we wanted to create a series that was unlike anything they ever had before, so for CCS we wanted to make a Nakayoshi-esque series. My first impulse was to write a magical-girl series, but I actually didn't know all that much about the mahou shoujo genre. But since I understand the feelings of girls who long for such things, I decided to give it a shot.

QUESTION: How did you conceive the story and characters?

OHKAWA: The heroines in MKR were middle-schoolers, so this time, from the very beginning, I wanted the heroine to be in the same age group as the majority of Nakoyoshi's readers (grades 4, 5, and 6). Moreover, I wanted the herioine to be a girl those same readers could look at and think, "I want to be like her." However- and I mean this in both a good and a bad way- that wasn't very Clamp-ish, so I made the other characters in the series more like our previous creations. Tomoyo-chan and Kero-chan fit that role. [...Who are they like? I think Touya is more typical of them.]

QUESTION: Which means you created Sakura first. How did you decide what kind of a girl she'd be?

OHKAWA: I wanted her to be great at sports but an otherwise normal student. *laughs* And I wanted her to be kind.

QUESTION: At what stage of planning do the other Clamp members start contributing?

MOKONA: When it's time to start drawing, actually.

OHKAWA: Since I don't talk about the characters until it's time to create their visual design, I take all the information I've gathered and have them design the characters based on the descriptions I give.

MOKONA: Ohkawa thinks up everything. Like their body build, their hair length, and even smaller details.

QUESTION: So when Nekoi-san designed Kero-chan...

OHKAWA: Same thing. I wanted our magical girl to have a mascot-type companion. But it wasn't as if I had already decided on a cat-like design.

NEKOI: I tried all sorts of forms, like dogs and squirrels.

QUESTION: Please tell us the process you went through for creating each of the characters, starting with Tomoyo-chan.

OHKAWA: I wanted a best friend who was in on the heroine's secret, someone to whom Sakura could talk about her magic. That

Tomoyo makes Sakura's costumes comes from the mahou shoujo convention of the heroine transforming in every episode- but I wanted to try having a friend prepare the costumes.

QUESTION: How about Yukito?

OHKAWA: I created Yukito-san in preparation of the ending of the Clow arc. Also, I wanted the heroine to have an older brother-ish person to long after. Such a warm, gentle character like Yukito is uncommon in Clamp.

QUESTION: Touya-oniichan?

OHKAWA: Onii-chan's type shows up a lot in our works. You know, the kind who says mean things but is actually a sweetheart.


QUESTION: Syaoran-kun?

OHKAWA: Syaoran might be that type too. It's a common for Clamp males. *laughs*

QUESTION: Do you have any anecdotes from when you were designing the characters?

MOKONA: When we first designed Sakura, I had the impression that she was more genki, that is, more of a aggressive tomboy, and, unfortunately, in the beginning Sakura's design was slightly off.

IGARASHI: This book has some of those initial designs, doesn't it? Since the series uses the current designs, I wonder if will label it "THE PHANTOM DESIGNS." *laughs*

MOKONA: Ohkawa told me, for the the art in general, to "use thin lines" and "don't use tsuri-me." 'Tsuri-me" reffers to the kind of eyes Kamui has in X. *laughs* She told me to avoid using those kind of straight lines, and to try to express things through curved lines.

OHKAWA: To unify the world view, I decide that kind of thing at the beginning. This is true for our other works. Because if I don't, the other works we're making end up, in spite of our best efforts, looking alike. [This happens anyway!]

MOKONA: She also told me to not draw stiff eyelashes. Like the ones in RG Veda. *laughs*

QUESTION: You really do set all the details. Does this mean you also chose the backgrounds and the tone treatment?

OHKAWA: Because I wanted the series to have a soft feel, I asked them to not use a lot of ink, to make the pages light. A lot of the readers thought that we must be cutting corners since the pages were so white. I asked Nekoi to make it "soft, cute-like."

NEKOI: But I didn't have experience with "cute-like" so...

IGARASHI: And all those flowers, it must've been so hard. I'm impressed. *laughs*

NEKOI: I looked hard for flowers we could use. I went through dictionaries, doing my best to find appropriate flowers. *laughs* I was trying to avoid using the same flower more than once in one chapter.

IGARASHI: We've never had to draw so many flowers for one series. *laughs*

NEKOI: There's surprisingly few flowers that can be drawn cutely.

QUESTION: Are there any flowers that you remember especially?

NEKOI: If you draw sunflowers the picture ends up looking idiotic. *laughs* I think we didn't use them more than once. Also, we had a lot of scenes where the boys were backed up by flowers. That was the hardest of all. We didn't want to use roses. *laughs*

QUESTION: Do you remember receiving specific instructions on the other characters?

MOKONA: I was told to make Yukito and Fujitaka to resemble each other a little.

OHKAWA: Because it would show up in the plot later.

MOKONA: Much later, I understood, "ohh, so that's why."

OHKAWA: I plan the stories out from beginning to end, but I never talk about it to the other members. I just hand them that chapter's script.

QUESTION: Does that mean you design characters like Yue as they appear in the story?

MOKONA: I think I designed Yue about a month before the chapter he showed up in.

QUESTION: Do you have any secrets on how you make Sakura so cute?

MOKONA: We pray. *laughs*


MOKONA: *laughs* Really, before I start drawing I pray, "may I draw a cute Sakura-chan." *laughs*

OHKAWA: I also pray that I'll write an interesting script. *laughs*

IGARASHI: "May I apply the tone well."

NEKOI: "May we meet the deadline." *laughs*

QUESTION: Do you really?!

NEKOI: Really, we do. We all pray. *laughs* But, drawing cute also depends on your mood, right?

MOKONA: Totally. Drawing cute and cool drawings alike depends on your mood. When I think "I'm so sleepy..." as I'm drawing, Sakura-chan's eyes get that far-away look. *laughs*

IGARASHI: When she's drawing Sakura smiling, Mokona is smiling too. *laughs*

NEKOI: I think it's like that for most drawings. When I'm drawing a smiling face I smile, when I draw someone crying I start wanting to cry too.

QUESTION: Do you feel that way when you're writing the scripts?

OHKAWA: No, not at all. *laughs*

MOKONA: Well, how cool of you. *laughs*

OHKAWA: Even when I'm writing a very serious scene, my emotions don't get dragged along.

QUESTION: There are writers who feel depressed when they write series scenes, but you...

OHKAWA: Not one bit. *laughs* But, lately I haven't been able to concentrate as much as I used to, so I change the background music and just like that I'm in the right mood.

QUESTION: What music did you use for CCS?

OHKAWA: I used a lot of female pop songs with cute voices. Yuuko Hara-san has a song called "Shoujo Jidai" ["Female Age"]. Everytime I listen to it I go back to when I first fell in love. It's bittersweet. *laughs* That's pretty much the kind of music I listened to.

QUESTION: Did Mokona Apapa-san listen to any specific music?

MOKONA: When I drew for CCS I used to listen to the anime OST. [What about before the anime was made?]

OHKAWA: I can't do that, when I hear the OST I get into the anime mindset.

QUESTION: Do all of you play your music out loud?

OHKAWA: In my work space I have a stereo, so if we play anything out loud it has to be on that. But since there are times some of us don't want to listen to what's playing, we have our own headphones to hear what we want to. There's also a separate drawing room we call "Siberia" where we can hide away.

MOKONA: It's cold in there. *laughs*

QUESTION: Where do you write the scripts?

OHKAWA: In the work room, with everyone else. It's where the computer is.

QUESTION: Does this mean you have to write serious scripts in what sounds like is a fun room?

OHKAWA: That's right. *laughs*

QUESTION: Please tell us the scene you remember the most from CCS.

MOKONA: For me, it's during the Athletics festival, where we find out how Tomoyo feels about Sakura. Up until then I had been drawing it so that it looked like Tomoyo was in love with Touya-oniichan, but that turned out to be wrong... I didn't find that out until I received that chapter's script. I was so surprised, "Ohkawa meant it to be that way?" I nearly fell out of my chair.

IGARASHI: I can't help but remember all the times I had to stick the magic symbols, or how much tone I had to apply to all the costumes. *laughs*

NEKOI: What I can't forget is drawing the over-view shot of the city. *laughs*

All of Them: Aaaaah. *laughs*

OHKAWA: What left an impression on me, and I was the one who decided this, was Sakura-chan without the strands of hair on the top of her head as a middle-schooler. *laughs* She looked so different. It may have been the secret to Sakura-chan's identity.

QUESTION: Have you gone back to read the series now that it's over?

MOKONA: Not yet. *laughs* I can't look at our series until about two years after the fact, when I can calmly see it as someone else's work.

QUESTION: How do you come up with the mid-series character/story key phrases?

OHKAWA: Indeed, how do I. *laughs*

NEKOI: It's because we're from Osaka. *laughs* All Osakan people have a Personal Motto. *laughs*

OHKAWA: *laughs* Before I started to write CCS, I had decided to write a story with filled with confidence for no particular reason. Because if you think that things won't well, that's usually where things head. I thought I could add the reason later. I wanted to it to be a "if you try your best, it'll work out" story. But I didn't start out with Sakura's "It'll definitely be okay" line in mind. It developed naturally as I wrote. In our works if you take one part, what the main character says, then that is what the work is trying to express. Since Sakura said that, I think that is what the series wanted to say.

QUESTION: I often hear that CCS inspires cheerfulness and motivation.

OHKAWA: If that's true then I'm glad.

QUESTION: In CCS there are certain relationships, like Tomoyo's feelings towards Sakura or Yukito's and Touya's relationship, that are not typical boy-girl romances. How do you, the creators, feel about that?

OHKAWA: Our works generally have a few main themes as well as other background themes I wanted to write. For CCS, and I don't know if this is the right way to put it, but I wanted to write something that minorities would feel comfortable with. Depending on your point of view, Tomoyo-chan's feelings for Sakura could be considered dangerous. Similarly, you can see Yukito and Touya as being friends, or as going beyond that. There's also how Syaoran was, at first, attracted to Yukito, and Rika's feelings [for Terada-sensei]. I took great care in how to portray all that.

OHKAWA: I mentioned this earlier, but the series's main theme is explored through the main character, so think of how Sakura-chan acts. For example, when she found out that Syaoran was in love with Yukito, she didn't look at him strangely. She did consider him a rival, but she didn't act as though it was weird. Or consider how Syaoran-kun is a foreigner. Sakura treats him as though he moved in from a neighboring town, and she admires him for being able to live alone-- she never once considers any of this as strange. Sakura herself doesn't have a mother, and she sees it as normal. I wanted a story with a protagonist who had an open mind towards different family structures, different kinds of love, and different perspectives from society.

OHKAWA: Maybe it's too much to hope that the younger readers will understand all that, but I do hope that they'll understand, a little bit, by looking at Sakura-chan. If they can, from Sakura-chan's example, learn how treat a child with only one parent or a peer from another country, I'll be happy.

OHKAWA: One last comment on the subject: I am glad that the readers are happy that Sakura and Syaoran got together, but that anyone would think it's because they make a normal couple... it's a little disconcerting. Sakura didn't chose Syaoran because he's a boy close to her in age. If Syaoran had been a girl, if they had been far apart in age, as long as he was still

Syaoran, I think Sakura would have fallen in love with him. It'd sadden me if you thought they're a good couple because they're normal.

QUESTION: Because of course you could have paired Sakura with Tomoyo.

OHKAWA: There is that. It's not because Tomoyo-chan is a girl that she didn't end up with Sakura. Of course Sakura does love Tomoyo, but it's not the kind of love she has for Syaoran. Moreover, Tomoyo wanted Sakura to be happy.

QUESTION: Tomoyo saying "My happiness is Sakura-chan's happiness" is quite memorable.

OHKAWA: If you ask me, the ultimate love is, when you think either "I want you to feel the same way about me," or "no matter what, I want you to be happy." I'm certain that Tomoyo, in thinking about Sakura, did feel that her happiness came from Sakura's happiness. And so she cast aside the "feel the same way about me" aspect of love. There may be people who think that elementary school children are incapable of such maturity, but there are many children who are that wise, and suffer for it.

OHKAWA: To those who think that a world like CCS doesn't exist, I tell them that's not true. There are children like that. There may not be many, but they do exist, really. There are children who are raised that purely, who are helpful, who respect their parents, and who are considerate of others. I've met such children. If you think they don't exist you might never meet them, but it's simply not true that "there is no such child."

QUESTION: Any secrets you can let out now that the series is over?

OHKAWA: More than secrets, there are things we decided that didn't come out in the series.

IGARASHI: For the CCS anime staff we made a book of character histories. Like how many siblings they have, or what kind of things they want to learn.

OHKAWA: But we do that for most of our works. It makes our lives easier later. *laughs*

QUESTION: I bet X's must be incredible.

IGARASHI: There are characters with extreme pasts. *laughs*

OHKAWA: Things like, "as a child they were put into solitary confinement." *laughs*

QUESTION: Each one of you, please tell us who your favorite character is.

OHKAWA: Tomoyo and Kero-chan.

IGARASHI: I've always had fun watching Nakuru. Even if she didn't appear much.

MOKONA: I also liked Nakuru-chan. She really did have few appearances. *laughs*

NEKOI: Mine is Fujitaka-otousan.

QUESTION: Are there any characters you'd want as a husband?

OHKAWA: Fujitaka-otousan. Even if he does have kids. *laughs*

NEKOI: I'd take Touya. *laughs*

IGARASHI: I'd marry Touya or Yamazaki-kun, he'd be fun in his own way.

OHKAWA: Oh, yeah, Yamazaki-kun is good.

NEKOI: He's good, isn't he. *laughs*

QUESTION: How about Syaoran-kun?

NEKOI: He might make a good younger brother, since he can cook.

MOKONA: Once he grows up to be a high-schooler I might reconsider him. *laughs*

OHKAWA: How about Yukito?

IGARASHI: Think of how much it'd cost to feed him. *laughs*

MOKONA: It'd be nice if he stayed as Yue.

OHKAWA: He seems like the kind of guy who can help with anything. *laughs*

MOKONA: Me, I'd marry Kero-chan. He'd help with the laundry, and when it was time to bathe he'd go right into the washing machine. *laughs*

QUESTION: It has to be someone good at housework?

OHKAWA: If he doesn't do housework, then I want him to have other skills. *laughs* Something amusing would be fine. *laughs*

QUESTION: We're coming to the end of the interview, so if you have anything you want to clear up about CCS...

OHKAWA: Actually Nekoi came up with the title Card Captor Sakura. We had decided on it being "Card Something Sakura," but I just couldn't come up with that "something." We were really close to the deadline when Nekoi suggested, "How about Card Captor Sakura?" "Oh, that's it," I said. *laughs* Though it's often misspelled into "Card Capchaa." *laughs*

MOKONA: There was "Card Caster" too, wasn't there. *laughs*

IGARASHI: And "Card Character." *laughs*

QUESTION: Lastly, each one of you please state one thought on CCS.

MOKONA: We'll never use so much pink again, will we. *laughs*

NEKOI: It was a challenge to see how shoujo a manga we could make.

IGARASHI: It was, in a large sense, a work of love.

OHKAWA: CCS was, in many ways, a happy series. Nakayoshi let us work with the content as we pleased, we were blessed with a good anime staff, and they let us, without any pressure for a sequel, finish the story where we wanted to. With such good fans, it really is a happy series.

If CCS is what they get when Ohkawa is trying to be normal, I wish they'd do it more often! I know Ohkawa likes to be naughty and try to go against the wood's grain, but CCS is quietly atypical in a way that blows, say, MKR away (whose purpose was to be unlike anything else in the genre). Its radicalness is derived from the fact that all those technically weird things (homosexual love, foreign students integrating so well into Japanese schools, students dating teachers) is taken for granted.

[User Picture]From: flowright
2005-04-22 05:26 am (UTC)
Really, we do. We all pray.
so making fun of the question ^^

I wanted a story with a protagonist who had an open mind towards different family structures, different kinds of love, and different perspectives from society.
that's the main impression i got from CCS and that's why I started to be clamp's fan. That was the very first time I read a story where homosexuality was not seen as taboo, weird or angst's folder. I will ove clamp forever just for that.

Things like, "as a child they were put into solitary confinement." *laughs*
Kakyou ? unless they pull that out from Aoki (the guy is TOO normal, that's not healthy ^^)

He seems like the kind of guy who can help with anything. *laughs*

but CCS is quietly atypical in a way that blows, say, MKR away
CCS is way superior than MKR, but I would conceed to MKR, a self parody tone that doesn't have CCS. And MKR's end is probably one of the best twist ever.
(Reply) (Thread)
[User Picture]From: usomitai
2005-04-22 05:41 am (UTC)
I will ove clamp forever just for that.

It definitely made me love them more.

Kakyou ?

My first thought was Karen! (who knows why.) It could've been one of the Earth Dragons- Seishirou, Satsuki, Yuuto... we don't know much about their childhoods.

And MKR's end is probably one of the best twist ever.

Oh, I give you that. I thought clamp was overall crap until I heard of the twist-- and then I became obsessed. >D And while MKR definitely has a more pronounced, deliberate style of self-parody, I don't like it so much (I prefer MKR 2 where the "this is so like a rpg!!!" jokes finally die down). I prefer CCS' approach. It feels more natural; MKR's parody felt like it was trying too hard.
(Reply) (Parent) (Thread)
[User Picture]From: flowright
2005-04-22 10:34 am (UTC)
> It could've been one of the Earth Dragons- Seishirou, Satsuki, Yuuto... we don't know much about their childhoods.

I wish they could do like shonen series and release their data book.

> I prefer MKR 2 where the "this is so like a rpg!!!" jokes finally die down

I like the characters much better in MKR 2... but on the other hand the end was so normal and disappointing
(Reply) (Parent) (Thread)
[User Picture]From: usomitai
2005-04-23 12:03 am (UTC)
I know! Why won't they release those data books? Throw in some recycled drawings and it'll sell like mad.

MKR 2's ending is fairly lame (I avoid looking at the last page of the manga, what's up with that?! I wonder how many people actually wrote down a name...) but I love the story so much I'll forgive it. <3
(Reply) (Parent) (Thread)
[User Picture]From: chibiyuuto
2005-04-22 04:42 pm (UTC)
Ow thank you so much for this very interesting interview ^__^

Ohkawa is just perfect... she doesn't get emotional when writing her stories! And her favorite chara is Tomoyo ! I can see that, really.

It was also good to see which part of the creation each of them worked, this is good because a lot of people think that Mokona does everything while Nekoi and Satsuki keeps in the corner playing with Kakyou XD

And again they confirmed that they don't know what's going to happen until they get the script from Ohkawa ^_^
(Reply) (Thread)
[User Picture]From: usomitai
2005-04-23 12:04 am (UTC)
while Nekoi and Satsuki keeps in the corner playing with Kakyou XD

Actually I thought it was only Satsuki who played with Kakyou. And maybe fed the other members. But now we know that she gets the boring end of the job like tone-filling. XXXD
(Reply) (Parent) (Thread)
[User Picture]From: elihice
2005-04-22 04:55 pm (UTC)
That was extremely interesting. It's okay if I post a link to this in the tsukimineshrine comm?
(Reply) (Thread)
[User Picture]From: usomitai
2005-04-23 12:00 am (UTC)
Thank you, and sure! :D I'm not sure if this is the where the final version will go (if there'll even BE a final version, hahahah) but I'd be glad if you link.
(Reply) (Parent) (Thread)
[User Picture]From: iamsocool12345
2005-04-22 08:02 pm (UTC)
Mmmm, good job, thank you so much for this!

I definitely agree with CCS being better just for being "normal"; everything big plays out quietly, but no less noticeably, and you can see CLAMP having fun with it as you read, which is so charming.

Present for you:
(Reply) (Thread)
[User Picture]From: usomitai
2005-04-23 12:10 am (UTC)
PUREZENTO. <3 (in .avi, nonetheless! YES) *puts modem to start downloading* Thankyouthankyouthankyou.
(Reply) (Parent) (Thread)
[User Picture]From: vikki
2005-04-23 02:38 am (UTC)
*LOVE*! Thank you so much for posting this interview. It fascinates me that they were intending to create a world where the minority groups were treated as a natural part of existance - and I liked that. These were things I never thought about deeply while reading it, but it's true that Sakura treats everyone equally with no consideration for gender preference, country of origin, family situation ... it's all very nice. :)

Thanks again!
(Reply) (Thread)
[User Picture]From: usomitai
2005-04-23 11:30 pm (UTC)
I'm glad you liked! Because the more people thinking [again] about CCS is a GOOD thing. ^_^

These were things I never thought about deeply while reading it, but it's true

Same here! Maybe it's because I take for granted that it's the RIGHT thing to do (treat everyone with equal consideration), and I'm glad not only that 1) CCS does this 2) Ohkawa pointed it out so that I can appreciate it.

PS: Amazing Misa cosplay. *_*
(Reply) (Parent) (Thread)
[User Picture]From: terada_sensei
2005-04-23 06:20 am (UTC)
You absolutely rock. Thanks so much for providing this translation for all CCS fans.

I'm a Sakura/Tomoyo fan, so it's nice to read about CLAMP's thoughts on the relationship. And though I'm not one, I know someone who's a Touya/Tomoyo fan, so that quote about Mokona drawing it as such for a few opening chapters is really, really interesting.
(Reply) (Thread)
[User Picture]From: usomitai
2005-04-23 11:27 pm (UTC)
Am glad you enjoyed. :D

I'm a Sakura/Tomoyo fan,

*GLOMPS* Kinship! They're my OTP. <3 (though I'm also partial to Touya/Tomoyo, hahahah. -_-) So what do you make of Clamp's thoughts in relation to S/T?

This went a LONG way to explain why Tomoyo looked like she was crushing on Touya first, which puzzled me for a while.
(Reply) (Parent) (Thread)
[User Picture]From: crisuskeer
2005-04-23 11:41 pm (UTC)
(Sorry; I'm jumping around my LJs. ^^;)

Whoo! What they said is really interesting, and I think I agree with their view (which should mean I interpreted her mostly correct based on what CLAMP wanted to express). Tomoyo loves Sakura a lot and would absolutely love it if the love is returned. However, she's not one to selfishly brood about that. She's mature enough (like CLAMP wants to show) to know that there are greater kinds of happiness than self-satisfaction. Or rather, she knows the world doesn't have to revolve around her.

It's not that Sakura's happiness is more important than Tomoyo's, but that Sakura's happiness is Tomoyo's. How could it be any different? You might think of that cliche about "If you love them enough, let them go" or something, but Tomoyo doesn't really say once that "You should be with me." If Sakura finds Tomoyo of her own will, then that's her own unpressured decision, and Tomoyo will welcome it. Otherwise, no remorse nor regrets.

(Reply) (Parent) (Thread)
[User Picture]From: frecklegirl
2005-05-07 03:40 am (UTC)
Ooh! I got here through clampfans, and I just have to say a huge thank you to you for doing this, it's so amazing. I've always wondered what the interview says. I tried to translate the text in the second movie memorial book, but I could only get as far as romanizing a paragraph or so *laughs* Oh well, someday I can get up to the translating level. Again, thanks so much!! <3 This interview revealed a lot!
(Reply) (Thread)
[User Picture]From: onion_mob
2005-06-28 04:33 am (UTC)
OMG, I love you forever!! I have the memorial book, and I was always trying to read that interview but couldn't! This is really interesting stuff. Personally I always felt like Sakura wound up with Syaoran just because it was "normal," which really upset me. I do appreciate how everyone is treated as "normal" in the story, but the ending feels like a cop-out.
(Reply) (Thread)
[User Picture]From: usomitai
2005-06-28 04:47 am (UTC)
The way I figure it, Sakura and Syaoran aren't your typical couple either; interracial (she's Japanese, he's from Hong Kong) which is still a no-no of sorts in Japan, and mildly incestuous? (he's descendant of Clow, she's the daughter of one half of Clow.)

But I know how you feel. :\
(Reply) (Parent) (Thread)
[User Picture]From: cherry_tiger
2007-02-03 05:02 am (UTC)
Thank you sooo much for posting this up! This has finally made a few things clear for me. Especially CLAMP's thoughts on Sakura and Syaoran. Ever since meeting a troll who said that the Sakura/Syaoran pairing was just fanservice and that Sakura was meant to be with Tomoyo, I was worried because unlike all the other CLAMP pairings, Sakura and Syaoran does seem a little normal.

But reading this, I beg to differ. They really did intend to pair Sakura up with Syaoran, whether he was a girl or something else, they still intended to pair her up with him. And that made me glad, cause I really do support Sakura and Syaoran. For Syaoran loved her and even took courage to confess that love to her even though there was a chance for it to be unrequited, and what's more he didn't expect an answer. I admired Syaoran so much for that. As for Sakura's feelings for Syaoran, it may look rushed, but rereading the manga I realize that Sakura has mentioned countless times that she feels stronger and better around Syaoran, which may mean she had loved Syaoran but never realized it. That's my take anyway...

The one thing I loved about CCS (and admired about Sakura) was how open minded the whole thing was. Seriously, if it weren't for this series and if it weren't for Sakura's happy outlook and non-judgemental thinking, I don't think I would've been able to be this open mided at all. I might've thought of yaoi as strange or something worst. -__- But CCS made me appreciate all of that.

Thus, no matter what, Cardcaptor Sakura has to be the best series from CLAMP ever for me. I know they came out with a lot of other good ones, but it will always be Cardcaptor Sakura for me. ^^

Again, thanks for putting this up!
(Reply) (Thread)
[User Picture]From: usomitai
2007-02-03 02:15 pm (UTC)
I don't see how you could doubt Clamp's otp-ness for Sakura and Syaoran, since they not only ended up together in CCS but are the main couple in TRC (with Tomoyo meeting Sakura only once). If they had meant Sakura to end up with Tomoyo, they'd have done it, trust me. :) The hints for S/S were built up over a long time, since at least vol. 4 of the manga.

And though, to us, they seem like a "normal" couple, they're abnormal in Japan. Marrying a foreigner is still a bit of a no-no, particularly to someone from China.

CCS is my favorite of theirs as well. :)
(Reply) (Parent) (Thread)